Strength and Vision in Post Conflict Bosnia and Herzegovina

IMG_3298 (3) Women of Life: Strength and Vision in Mostar  By Danielle Bonner

Have you ever met a person and sensed there is something special about them? Since joining the NCCWN Donegal Women’s Network advocating for women’s rights and equality I have had the privilege of meeting inspirational women who have opened my eyes to the strength and vision of women all around the world. What I have come to find fascinating is the unique life story every woman holds. I have as one friend would say found my gender lens!

This summer I travelled to Mostar in Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH), Mostar is one of the largest and culturally diverse cities in BiH with a population of 113,169[1] and a city that experienced great devastation during the country’s 1992-1995 war. While the war ended with the signing of the Dayton Peace Agreement in 1995 Mostar however remains a city with great ethnic divisions, the city can be seen to be divided into two halves with Croats predominately residing on the west side and Bosniaks (Muslims) residing on the east side.

IMG_9683It can be easy when you arrive in Mostar to become focused on the multiple post conflict development issues like when I first visited in 2013 and the first thing that struck me was the multiple damaged or destroyed buildings avid remaining visions of the conflict. On this visit however I had the opportunity to live with locals and engage in conversations on a one to one level.

IMG_3135For four weeks I stayed in the family run Hostel Nina Mostar on the east side of the city where I met the very cheerful and lovely owner Jadranka or as everyone calls her (Beba). One night in conversation with her she remarked that she had a mixed marriage which in Mostar meant she was a Croat and her husband a Bosniak. She made light of the fact that during the former Yugoslavia mixed marriages were encouraged but in the aftermath of the war which left nearly 100,000[2] dead, people said that these marriages would not last, though this was not the case for Beba and her husband.

I was taken by her comment and openness and was interested to hear more about her life as a woman, so I asked if she would be happy to sit down with me and talk about life in Mostar, and to my excitement she said yes. It was a warm sunny afternoon and my last day in Mostar when we sat in the hostel garden to talk again. Before we began Beba lit up a cigarette and joked all women in Mostar smoke! This friendly humour would set the tone of our conversation and I knew I was about to be enlightened by this unique and humorous lady.

No politics was her request and I assured her it was not about the politics I wanted to talk about but the human story of a woman who had experienced conflict and went on to develop a successful business post conflict.

She started by telling me she had studied law when she was younger and then went into accounting. At 19 she was married and when the war broke out she was 33. While we did not go into the politics of the war she remarked that the war was imposed by others and that they were made to leave their homes without thought or care. It was also difficult for her because she did not take sides but people knew who she was because of her last name.

In 1992 like 2 million[3] other displaced persons in Bosnia she and her two children had to leave the family home to eventually become refugees in Norway. Having had to leave her husband in Mostar she had no direct contact with him for two years but for messages sent via the Red Cross. She spoke of the contrast and shock of living in Norway where there was no conflict and families could freely walk around.

By 1994 however she felt she could no longer be apart from her husband and made the decision to return to her home with their two young children then 11 and 5 years old. She spoke of her concern that she would not recognise him in the years apart and that when she arrived back in Bosnia she had to go through check points and road blocks and say she was visiting family on the other side. When she finally arrived at the checkpoint to meet her husband she explained that he had lost weight and she only recognised him by the old shorts he wore.

Arriving back to the home she had left 2 years prior she was presented with complete destruction. For some years the family faced challenges and she recalled having to wash clothes down by the river, living without electricity or proper windows. It was not easy to start the rebuilding and she worked to get as much money as she could, as it was difficult for her husband to find paid work. She worked for an Italian aid organisation for three years which supported the development of the community.

IMG_9621By 2004 with the reconstruction of the Old Bridge (Stari Most) things started to improve for the city and for her family. In the same year her sister gave her an apartment to rent to tourists on the westside, she explained how she would wait at the bus station for tourists and offer them this accommodation.

One day while waiting she met a lady from New Zealand and they hosted her in their own home. It turned out the lady was actually a tourist guide and she encouraged Beba to set up a website and promote the hostel. Soon after she invested in a computer and every year the same lady would send people to visit the hostel.

Beba spoke freely about her experience and then while listening to my friend translate my questions there was a little laughter from her, I asked why she was laughing and they explained that they were talking about a book she discovered in 2008 that really inspired her and gave her further determination to fulfil her ambition to build her home and make the hostel a successful business.

To my surprise she was referring to the book “The Secret” a book my own mother has read and found inspiring. I started to laugh too because she then explained that she had tried to get others to read the book but they thought she crazy because a book could not bring empowerment.

In 2008 things again started to positively change for the business, they received a traveller from France who went on to leave a positive comment on facebook about his time with Beba and her family, which then followed a series of further positive comments and recommendations from other guests.

Beba spoke of the funny memories too, like when she served guests breakfast out in the garden and the table would wobble because of a hole in the ground still remaining from the conflict and their old car that looked like it was falling apart yet it still managed to get them around and take guests on tours.

I must have spent over two hours speaking with Beba on that sunning afternoon and I could have spent many more hours with her talking. I ended our conversation by asking what would she say to future women in Mostar? She replied “people can be fake, materialist and just want to make an impression, but this is not what gets you places, people think too you have to be lucky, but you have to work, be active and take what opportunities you can”. Everyone has to get on with life she concluded.

For me Beba is a woman of strength and vision, she is a positive example of the great value women bring to their societies, for Bosnia and Herzegovina a society trying to move away from the effects of conflict her vision and the warm and friendly embrace she gave me and all the other guests who come through her home, serves to help build a tourist industry and economic growth, she is therefore an example of the women who are an economic driving force in Mostar.

IMG_6393On a personal level my afternoon with Beba has been one of great learning about the effect of conflict on women’s lives. While my talk with her demonstrates that regardless of language and cultural differences no matter where we are in the world at the end of the day we are all human beings who have the ability to form bonds over the simplest of things, which in turn allows us to interact and form dialogue which provides personal grow and wider social understanding.

[1] 2013 PRELIMINARY Census RESULTS http://www.bhas.ba/obavjestenja/Preliminarni_rezultati_bos.pdf [2] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/6228152.stm [3] (Women, War, and Politics in Bosnia- Herzegovina, Marie E. Berry, UCLA, Research Country: Bosnia- Herzegovina, August, 2013) http://www.irex.org/sites/default/files/Berry%2012-13%20Research%20Brief.pdf

Why Peacebuilding is important to me

In September I was asked by the Red Elephant Foundation to write about my peacebuilding and advocacy work and my ambition to help Afghans bring peace to their country.  Here is my frank peace talk entitled “Building Peace, Brick by Brick“.

Admiring the Art in Mostar, Bosnia and Herzegovina

Could you tell us something about your work in Afghanistan?
I volunteer for PaxPopuli an organisation which advocates for peace in Afghanistan and runs an on-line tutoring programme for Afghan students. In my role as a Social Media Communications Manager my working objective is to build the organisations advocacy voice and partnerships. At present Pax is a small organisation run solely by its volunteers, but its aim is to grow and help more Afghan students develop their skills and enable both students and tutors to experience and learn about each other’s cultures through interacting in the program.

Why Afghanistan?
Well, really my interest began after following the new coverage post 9/11 though when I began my Peace and Conflicts Masters in 2009 that my interest grew further. I wrote my thesis paper on the state-building process in Afghanistan post 2001 and it was during my research that I started to see the country’s potential to develop and move away from its violent past given support. This is why I enjoy my work with Pax Populi because it has given me the opportunity to support Afghans and connect with others working to bring stability and development to the country.

There is so much to war that goes unnoticed. But we cannot always offer them up for all to see. Why is that?
One thing I have come to observed is that mainstream news is a business as such its news coverage is designed to sell and to attract audience numbers. For example here for me watching UK new coverage of conflict, there is often a focus on the politics of a situation and the possible involvement of the military. Take Afghanistan for example, post 2001 there was much focus on the military intervention to remove the Taliban, but in 2003 the war became very much the forgotten war due in part to the military operation into Iraq.

It was only once the military started to withdraw from Iraq that focus went back to Afghanistan and headlines covered military lose and why the international community was still there. The same can be said of the conflict in Syria, a conflict which has been going on now for over two years, and even though everyday within those years there has been ongoing violence and destruction we have had a wave of varying news coverage.

It may also be the case that because there have been so many different conflicts in recent years, a situation has been created whereby when the public see news headlines of conflict to them one war really starts to sound like all those prior, as a result they turn away in the belief they have heard this all before. It is this type of situation which then reinforces news media to cover stories which the public will feel connected with like any national political involvement or military action in a conflict.

What are your thoughts about the West’s ideas of intervention and war? Are you a believer in the orthodoxies of international relations, that a state’s sovereignty cannot be messed around with through intervention, or are you the modern thinker?
I do believe in the importance of maintaining and respecting International Relations and Sovereignty, and while I don’t like war, I do understand how wars are started and how interventions can be justified. What concerns me however is the failure of the international community to agree a strategy on how to deal with ongoing conflicts. There is R2P (Responsibility to Protect), but in practice what does this mean?

Take the situation with Syria, there is an estimated 2 million displaced Syrians with a further 100,000 now killed. Would this not be a case for intervention? While there is condemnation of the situation as we see there is no international agreement or even support for such an intervention? It does not help that leading powers have competing interests which governs the side they will take in addressing a conflict. I have mixed feelings about any such international military action, because as past interventions have shown the international community are ill prepared to deal with the aftermath of their actions, which defeats the very intention of stopping further conflict. What I am in favour however of increased humanitarian support, to ensure that those being impacted by conflict have better access to water, food, housing and education, and the like.

Wars have the worst impact on women – be it through sexual violence or through the systemic destruction of their families. Do you agree?
Yes I would agree, and while it’s true to say that everyone living through conflict is an equal victim, there is no escaping that it is women who are the worse impacted by war and conflict. It is a sad fact that women are seen as easy targets which is proven by the countless cases of sexual violence against women in war zones. (See UN Rape: Weapon of war) Women are left vulnerable in the environment of war because they have no real to defend themselves from this weapon of war.

The targeting of woman is strategic, because through sexual violence the aggressor has a way to not only inflect physical and psychological damage on the victim but also has a way to break up families and divide communities through the sigma and cultural violations this type of violence brings. And while there is international law with the UN Resolution 1820 which aims to protect women in conflict it is still the case that violence against women in conflict is widespread.

Is there a possibility for Afghanistan to rise above this turmoil? What do you believe would be the remedy to the trauma the country has been put through?
Those who may not know the history of Afghanistan may view the conflict as a 12 year war but the reality is conflict has played a destructive role in the lives of Afghans since the era of Empires. Notably the cold war and the invasion of the Soviet Union have all played their part in the country’s history of conflict. While it is also Afghanistan’s misfortune to be a land locked nation sandwiched within what has been described as a tough neighbourhood. The geopolitics within the region plays its part in the destabilization of Afghanistan with various actors taking advantage of the periods of conflict.

Through these histories and existing structures I have come to view the conflict within Afghanistan as “a story within a story” there are many layers which affect the ongoing conflict, some of which have come to overlap each other and then creating new conflicts. It is a pool of challenges which need to equally be addressed, there is no one dose of medication which will fix all problems. But that does not mean we can’t start somewhere. And while Afghanistan can’t escape its history it can learn from its past to create a better future. Ensuring all Afghans receive an education is therefore vital in ensuring that the country has the capacity and skills required to develop the country. While a reconciliation process needs to take place not just with the Taliban but also between the different ethnic groups within the country where there are hostilities caused from past conflicts.

As a peacebuilder in Afghanistan, does anything threaten you? What worries you most about your works?
I worry about the safety of those Afghans I interact with; it is difficult to imagine that because you want peace for your country and are outspoken to the fact that some within your society are preventing this peace or as a female the desire to have an education could threaten your life, but in Afghanistan this is a reality. I’m therefore always conscious that when I’m asking people in Afghanistan to do something on behalf of Pax Populi, like take part in one of our campaigns I am not adversely placing a threat to their life.

Having been involved in peace work for the last few years I also recognise that the development of peace or what we call peacebuilding is a long process which requires both the investment of time and resources. However in practice this is something I feel gets forgotten in the rush to bring stability to a society, as a result what we have seen is that many societies in fact laps back into conflict. I’ve written a blog piece about this very issue entitled “The internal battle for Peace”, which looks at the meaning of Peacebuilding, the conceptual, technical and political factors surrounding the idea and practice.

Tell us about your many different initiatives for Afghanistan.
Pax Populi operates an English tutoring service, and we do a lot of peace advocacy through social media and develop initiative campaigns. For example for International Women’s Day in March we developed the “Be Inspired” project, which included a collection of profiles and portrait moments highlighting the roles Afghan women are playing in society and their experiences as women in Afghanistan. We also sought the views of Afghan men, women, community organisations and Politicians through conducting over 30 interviews all of which are profiled on the website.

Supporting peace for all afghans

Currently we are getting ready to celebrate International Peace Day on Sept 21 with our initiative ”Voices for Peace”, which will highlight the work being done in Afghanistan to build peace, while also creating international community of support through showcasing the views of people around the world on what peace means and how we can build peace. We also like to give Afghans the opportunity to share their voice through writing and we have many insightful blog pieces written by students and supporters in Afghanistan on issues concerning their lives and educational pieces which gives the reader into life in Afghanistan. I am really proud of the work done by Pax Populi, because everything one involved is a volunteer and we are very resourceful at finding ways to connect with Afghans and others around the world promoting peace in our unique way.

There is a lot of talk about how the status of women in the aftermath of the troop draw down could find itself in a position that’s worse than what it is now. What are your thoughts on this?
There is much concern over the rights of women in Afghanistan because while they have achieved much over the last 12 years many challenges still remain. There are still attitudes within Afghan society which do not respect the rights of women especially the right to an education, these challenges are social issue within Afghanistan which need to be addressed not just by the enforcement of law in relation to women’s rights but also through educating those who do not believe in these rights.

The schedule drawdown of international troops has placed further pressure not only on the Afghan government but the international community to enter into negotiations with the Taliban in order to bring an end to violence within the country; this has led some to be concern that women’s rights will become scarified in return for a political settlement with the Taliban. It is therefore important that both the Afghan government and the international community do not support any such move that restrict the rights of women and they enforce human rights into any future political agreement.

One thing that gives me confidence in the future of women in Afghanistan is the new generation of Afghans, those who have experience life without the restrictions of the past and who want to work to ensure their country is not drawn back into its days of suppression.

If you want to get the views of Afghans themselves on women’s rights in Afghanistan please check out the Pax Populi women’s day project which features the views of over 30 Afghan men, women and community organisations.